Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Cummiskey: Carbery to Munster deal looms

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Cummiskey: Carbery to Munster deal looms

    Carbery rejects Ulster move as possible Munster deal looms

    Ulster still seeking permission to sign an established international outhalf

    about 3 hours ago
    Gavin Cummiskey

    Having seemingly rejected a loan move to Ulster, Joey Carbery is now being guided towards a one-season deal with Munster.
    Ireland coach Joe Schmidt is keen for Carbery to be a starting outhalf in the Champions Cup next season. The 21-year-old has been the back-up Irish 10 ever since Paddy Jackson was suspended, pending a disciplinary hearing after his rape trial, for which he was found not guilty yet subsequently fired by the IRFU.
    However, this season, Carbery has become third choice Leinster outhalf with just one underwhelming start at 10, in the defeat to Treviso last month, and he also started just once for Ireland, against Fiji in November, when forced out of action for two months with a fractured arm.
    The IRFU have reportedly blocked Ulster’s well-advanced move to sign Springbok Elton Jantjies which leaves them entering the off-season without a senior outhalf.
    Carbery is represented by Esportif’s Ryan Constable, who is also Jackson’s agent, while the same company did the deal for Dan McFarland to become Ulster head coach. However, McFarland is contracted to the Scottish Rugby Union until January so negotiations for a release from his current job as forwards coach under Gregor Townsend, also repped by Esportif, remain unresolved.
    So, as it currently stands, Ulster are without an international-calibre outhalf or a date for their new head coach’s arrival. Johnny McPhillips, the English born 21-year-old, is their only recognised 10.
    Leinster want Carbery and Ross Byrne to remain on their roster at least until their contracts end in June 2020. A loan deal requires one of them to verbally seek a release from the club, the reason would be to secure game time in a World Cup season.
    This is unlikely to happen in the lead up to Saturday’s Pro 14 final at the Aviva stadium.

    “My view has always been, and still is, you do what’s right for the player,” said Leinster coach Stuart Lancaster after The Sunday Times revealed that IRFU performance director David Nucifora and Schmidt approached Leinster about releasing Carbery or Byrne.
    “You put the player at the centre of the decision, so you don’t do anything other than that. I think Joey has developed brilliantly at Leinster and I think this is where he should stay.”
    There is growing evidence that Leinster view Byrne as Johnny Sexton’s eventual successor – having used him at outhalf 26 times this season for 1560 minutes – with Carbery increasingly seen as a fullback.
    Overriding ambition

    Interestingly, Schmidt is at the heart of this player movement process but he communicates directly with the player and not the provinces.
    The Ireland coach’s overriding ambition is a successful World Cup campaign so he is understandably keen to avoid the very situation that proved so damaging at RWC 2015. When Ian Madigan, who has since left Ireland to join Pat Lam at Bristol via Bordeaux, replaced Sexton at outhalf for the quarter-final against Argentina he had primarily been used at inside centre, fullback or off the bench because former Leinster coach Matt O’Connor preferred New Zealander Jimmy Gopperth.
    Madigan is not currently being considered for Ireland selection and along with other exiles, like Donnacha Ryan and Simon Zebo, he will not be named in the squad to tour Australia in June (due to be announced today).
    Munster gave Ian Keatley a new contract last year after he regained the starting berth following injury to Tyler Bleyendaal and Bill Johnston.
    JJ Hanrahan returned from Northampton on a lucrative deal but the Kerry native was unable to remove Keatley from the starting XV until after the Champions Cup semi-final loss to Racing 92. Hanrahan missed a 28th minute penalty, in front of the posts, before limping out of Saturday’s Pro 14 semi-final defeat to Leinster at the RDS (when Byrne played 10 for Leinster with Carbery at 15).
    Hanrahan, Keatley and Bleyendaal – who is recovering from his latest neck surgery – all have one season to run on their provincial deals. Johnston, a genuine prospect who showed well for Garryowen and Munster A this season, recently signed a two-year contract.
    Johnston was outhalf on the James Ryan-led side that beat New Zealand en route to the 2016 Junior World Cup final.
    Should Carbery take the advice of joining Munster to enhance his international prospects, one of the aforementioned outhalves might be redirected from Limerick to Belfast.
    All the while Ulster continue to seek permission to sign an established international outhalf to replace Jackson.
    Something’s got to give soon.
    Munster – Champions of Europe 2006, 2008, 2020.

    #2
    If true (big if), would Carberry only be available from end Sep / early Oct assuming he's travelling to Australia? This means that he only has a single game (most likely against Leinster) to prepare for a first champions cup game. This is a far from ideal preparation in a new team.

    Comment


      #3
      Obviously clickbait but that aside, I'd be of the opinion that under no circumstances should we take him on for a year. We're not Leinsters development hub.
      forti et fideli nihil difficile

      Comment


        #4
        Would have him all day long. Quality player, one year or not.

        Comment


          #5
          I'd be slightly more enthusiastic about it if it was for a longer term. But as Munsterboy said in the match thread do we really want a player who's heart ain't in it? For Joey himself he should obviously make the best decision for him and his, but none of this actually came from him it was all Joe/IRFU. You can't force a player to jump ship particularly when they're still under contract.
          forti et fideli nihil difficile

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by Scrum Five View Post
            Obviously clickbait but that aside, I'd be of the opinion that under no circumstances should we take him on for a year. We're not Leinsters development hub.
            Precisely. This would be nothing short of an insult.
            "It’s not the team you support, it’s the club you should support. The team on the pitch will ebb and flow because that’s the nature of sport. No team has ever been successful decade on decade. The club has the history and that’s the passion you should have."

            Comment


              #7
              If Joe Schmidt wants Carbery to learn his trade as an Outhalf, then he should go back to Clontarf and play AIL or else instruct Leo/Stuart to pick him at Ten when Jonny is being rested.

              Comment


                #8
                Also just to disclaim I have nothing against Joey Carbery he is a talented rugby player and seems a sound human being but I don't see it being of benefit to Munster. We need to be giving Bill Johnston start's at 10 and if he comes in for a year that won't happen. What happens then in 2020 when he swannys back to the south side? Bills development is neither here nor there and we're back to square one.. Sorry rant over now
                forti et fideli nihil difficile

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by rua13 View Post
                  Would have him all day long. Quality player, one year or not.
                  is leinster's 3rd choice outhalf really what you're looking for ?

                  I wouldn't have thought so.
                  I always knew Madigan was a closet Scrum Half. Ignore All things that suggest Continuity.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by The Outlaw View Post
                    is leinster's 3rd choice outhalf really what you're looking for ?

                    I wouldn't have thought so.
                    Enjoy our third choice number 8 :)

                    Comment


                      #11
                      A one year deal. Is this a joke? Play him in the Leinster A team, or here's a thought, select him at 10 in the senior leinster team. Hope Munster tells IRFU to stuff it

                      Adding Baldy's excellent post from the match thread.

                      Going back to the suggestion that Carbery move to Munster. I would guess it's unlikely but I would have to say it would really stick in the craw. I really admire the lads who have moved south and made a real go of it by their own choice.
                      We might be behind that blue shower at the moment but I'll be damned if we need their ****ing charity or the charity of the IRFU. Loaning out Cadbury to us for a season to help us out. How very kind of them to give us the opportunity.
                      Goddamit but our team and our 4 outhalves need to shake themselves up to **** next season and perform to the utmost of their ability.
                      I'm sick to death of these ****ing patronising wankers in the media constantly being condescending to Munster.
                      I know it's the end of season but I'm mad as hell listening to all this crap. For sure Munster have serious deficiencies but we're not too far off the mark. A decent pre season free from the rash of injuries and we'll be close.
                      We are all Munster and I'd hope to goodness we can do it our own way with the players at our disposal.
                      If I'm mad as hell I expect the players to be much worse. These are proud men and I expect they'll apply themselves to the task at hand next season.

                      For now it's break time but I can't wait for the new season.

                      Up Munster and **** the begrudgers.
                      Last edited by FORWARD....; 23rd-May-2018, 09:07.
                      "Fineen Wycherley was everywhere. When I watched this video back late on Saturday night I half expected to look up from my laptop to find him in my kitchen ' TRK Nov 3rd 2019 following Cardiff v Munster

                      Comment


                        #12
                        If true, this suggestion is outrageous. If Carbery can refuse to go to Ulster then Keatley & JJ should refuse point blank to go to Ulster. They both have contracts with Munster (not CC's needless to say) and should stay to see them out.
                        This is the kind of crap I was referring to in the thread I started 'Have the IRFU got too much control over Munster'. We need to 'Stand Up and Fight' otherwise we are just being used a pawns in Joe's & the IRFU's interests.
                        They have screwed us over D.Ryan & Zebo (& Copeland I'm guessing) already, enough is enough.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Ulster don't want them. I'd rather play our young fellas over any of the 3 suggested.

                          We are rebuilding from the ground up, we need to do that with our own OH.

                          It sounds like Joey runs the IRFU at the minute, and he's not even good enough to be 2nd choice at Leinster. All very strange.

                          Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
                          Commemorate Nevin Spence here -
                          http://www.mycharity.ie/event/munste..._nevin_spence/

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Scrum Five View Post
                            Obviously clickbait but that aside, I'd be of the opinion that under no circumstances should we take him on for a year. We're not Leinsters development hub.
                            Agreed. However all 4 provinces are nothing but breeding grounds for 'The National Team' in IRFU's eyes. And at the moment Leinster are 'Ireland Junior' as they see it. All roads lead to Ballsbridge.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              No way we sign him on a loan deal for 1 year, that just stirring **** from that muppet Cummiskey.
                              If he signs then I would imagine we take over his remaining 2 year contract from Leinster.

                              IF it did happen.
                              Bill J is staying, he just signed a 2 year contract.
                              Keatley I doubt would move, he just started a family in Limerick.
                              JJ is on decent wages and wouldn't be cheap for Ulster.
                              TB? No idea on his medical prognosis.

                              We simply couldn't sustain 5 OH's so something would need to happen with JJ and/or TB imo.


                              Leinster more than any team have done better than any from utilising players from other provinces. Reddan, Boss, S Cronin, M Ross, Henshaw all were Irish starters at times and all have >20 caps. No other province has benefited like that shower.
                              Last edited by Tobyglen; 23rd-May-2018, 10:16.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X