No announcement yet.

The Hybrid Rower - Part 3


  • The Hybrid Rower - Part 3, the Irish Hybrid


    One of the positions of most interest and competition in the Irish world cup squad is that of the fourth second row spot. Is there even a fourth spot? In 2007, O’Sullivan selected three second-rows: O’Connell, O’Callaghan and O’Kelly. Donncha had just wrested the first choice spot alongside O’Connell from Big Mal: O’Callaghan started all 2007 6 Nations matches, having only started one the previous year, whereas O’Kelly had only missed two starts from the previous seven 6 Nations tournaments. O’Kelly turned 33 in July 07, making him roughly the same age that Leo Cullen is as he approaches this world cup, and went on to play a major role in Leinster’s HEC triumph of 09, so it’s fair to say that he still had quite a lot left in the tank. Unfortunately, O’Sullivan’s appalling use of the bench ensured that he never even saw a minute of gametime in four games of RWC07, but maybe that’s another days topic.

    In any case, we used only two second rows through that tournament, leaving the third redundant. It’s fair to say that we were thus very unlikely to press a fourth into use, but Alan Quinlan would nominally have been the hybrid, a backrow-cum-secondrow [and very much in that order].

    I think it’s safe to assume that the three top second rows in Ireland going into this World Cup are Paul O’Connell, Donncha O’Callaghan and Leo Cullen. With the exclusion of Leinster’s Devin Toner and Ulster’s Dan Tuohy from Kidney’s preparatory RWC Squad, two of the twenty-something locks regularly plying their trade in the provinces, the spotlight has turned again to the hybrid ‘rower. Three of them have been selected in this initial squad: Mike McCarthy [Connacht], Donnacha Ryan [Munster] and Kev McLaughlin [Leinster]. At 29, McCarthy is uncapped at test level; Ryan [27] has 7 caps, all from the bench; and McLaughlin [26] has a single cap, a start against Italy in the 2010 6 Nations.

    Physically, they’re cut from similar enough cloth, with Ryan being a little taller and sparer than the other two: McCarthy is 193cm [6’4”] and 110kg [17st1lb]; Ryan 198cm [6’6”] and 108kg [16st13lb] and McLaughlin 193cm [6’4”] and 109kg [17st1lb].

    McCarthy [from what I can tell from a variety of sources, their website being somewhat unco-operative] started all 22 matches of Connacht’s Magner’s League Campaign, and 5 of their 6 games in the Amlin Challenge Cup
    He made seven starts @ blindside:
    Ulster x2, Dragons, Scarlets, Glasgow, Cardiff, Ospreys [all ML]
    Second Row:
    McCarthy made twenty starts @ second row:
    Leinster x2, Munster x2, Treviso x2, Aironi x2, Edinburgh x2, Dragons, Scarlets, Glasgow, Cardiff,
    Ospreys [all ML]
    Harlequins x2, Bayonne x2, Cavalieri [all ACC]
    That’s a very impressive 27 starts [and he was on the bench for the game against Cavalieri Prato on 9th October] from 28 competitive games that Connacht played this season: 20 of them in the second row, and 7 of them at blindside. If any Connacht fans have more accurate information than that, I’m all ears – I’ve had to trawl a couple of sources and could easily have got some things mixed up.

    Ryan played 26 times for Munster this year, starting 18 games and coming off the bench 8 times.
    His seven starts @ blindside all came in the ML, against:
    Aironi x2, Dragons, Leinster, Ospreys, Ospreys [MLSF] and Leinster [MLGF].
    He made three appearances off the bench into the backrow:
    vs Brive [AC]; vs Toulon [HEC] and vs Glasgow [ML].
    Of his eleven starts @ second-row, 1 was in the HEC vs London Irish, and 10 came in the ML:
    Connacht x2, Edinburgh x2, Scarlets, Ulster, Treviso, Leinster, Glasgow, Ospreys
    He made five appearances off the bench into the second row:
    vs Quins [AC]; vs Toulon [HEC] and vs Cardiff, Treviso and the Ospreys [all ML]

    All in all then, he played in 10 games as a blindside, and 16 as a second-rower – an ideal blend.

    McLaughlin only came back to rugby after Christmas, having recovered from the surgery following his injury in the 09-10 ML Grand Final against the Ospreys. He played 15 times for Leinster, starting 12 and coming off the bench 3 times.
    He made seven starts @ blindside in the ML:
    Connacht, Scarlets, Treviso, Scarlets, Dragons, Munster, Ulster;
    and three in the HEC: Leicester [QF]; Toulouse [SF]; Northampton [F]
    He made three appearances off the bench into the backrow:
    Saracens [HEC], Ulster [MLSF], Munster [MLGF]
    Second Row
    He had two starts @ second row in the ML:
    Aironi, Glasgow
    In all, he played in 13 games as a blindside, and 2 as a second-rower. He may also have switched into second row from flanker in a couple of ML matches when a substitute flanker came on, but literally only one or two games.

    So, if you look at the data assembled there, it’s clear that in that sub-group of hybrids we have one guy who has primarily played in the second row [McCarthy], one guy who has primarily played on the blindside [McLaughlin] and one guy who has split time not quite evenly, but moreso than the other two, down the middle of the two positions [Ryan]. McCarthy has a lot of miles on the clock this season [27 starts!] with Ryan some way behind him at 18 starts and McLaughlin bringing up the rear [or fresher, depending on how you want to see it] at 12 starts.

    Now the beauty of a training camp is that Kidney, Smal and Kiss will see these guys go up against each other on a daily basis out on the pitch, as well as in the gym. On a more holistic level, they’ll see how they interact with the other players around the complex – some guys make better tourists than others, and it’s not to be sniffed at if skill levels and physicality are pick ‘ems. This is all internal stuff within the squad and the management, which the great majority of us won’t ever really know.

    What we’ll get to see is the warm-up matches: five of them. Obviously some units won’t be used to working together [like at lineout time] so it’s worth bearing in mind that we won’t necessarily be seeing incredibly polished performances from these three guys. What will be worth checking out are the basics of their play – their workrate, their tackling, their ferocity at the breakdown/ruck, their handling and [most eye-catchingly] their carrying into contact.

    I’d be surprised if we don’t see one of these guys going, but I’d be pretty shocked if we saw more than one. The one player who I haven’t included [as he hasn’t really played much second row, if any, at senior level] is Stephen Ferris. He has the physique and the aggression to be a genuinely great hybrid, a big hard bruiser who just loves to bash it up into people when he has the ball and to smash them when he doesn’t. Here’s hoping for a dark horse.
    Attached Files
      Posting comments is disabled.



    Latest Articles


    • Squeaky Bum Time approaches
      by mr chips
      (By Piquet - not my work!)

      That time of the season so beloved of Sir Alex Ferguson is coming into view.

      There will have to be major rule changes next year, given that of all the Premiership teams, only one, Saracens, are not in the bottom half of their Pool.
      Peculiarly enough, of the ten fixtures in Round Four, only three had different results from the previous Round.
      Significant gaps have developed in three of the pools and the first four casualties...
      9th-January-2019, 10:35
    • Piquet's Half Time Analysis
      by mr chips
      Right, we’re at the Halfway stage both in the Head to Head games and overall.

      In the old days, if you lost your first match, you didn't win the Heineken Cup. Munster put a stop to that in 2006. Then, if you lost your first two matches, you were out. With the change in format to allow three rather than two Pool runners up go through, that went by the wayside two years ago courtesy of Bath.

      Gerry Thornley in the Irish Times had an interesting article last week...
      13th-December-2018, 21:12
    • World Cup: it's not easy being green
      by ozoyo
      by SYRIANA

      The Rugby World Cup is a matter of weeks away and the various squads are being finalised by managers from Canada to New Zealand. The favourites are, predictably, New Zealand and pre-tournament speculation is rife. ...
      16th-August-2011, 07:54
    • On the Road again with McGahan's Fusiliers
      by ozoyo

      Munster finished the 2010/2011 season as league champions, scored another famous victory over an International side and made it to a semi-final of a European Competition, why then, are many fans questioning where Tony McGahan is leading Munster rugby?...
      8th-August-2011, 06:45
    • The Hybrid Rower - Part 3, the Irish Hybrid
      by ozoyo
      by HUGONAUT

      One of the positions of most interest and competition in the Irish world cup squad is that of the fourth second row spot. Is there even a fourth spot? In 2007, O’Sullivan selected three second-rows: O’Connell, O’Callaghan and O’Kelly...
      6th-August-2011, 13:53
    • The Hybrid Rower - Part 1
      by ozoyo
      by HUGONAUT

      In theory, it’s hard to argue against the logic of the hybrid rower - a big strong athlete who is physically strong enough to survive the tight grind of scrummaging and mauling, tall enough to act as a primary lineout option...
      6th-August-2011, 13:44