Page 6 of 25 FirstFirst ... 4567816 ... LastLast
Results 151 to 180 of 734
  1. #151
    Sin Binned
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Netherlands
    Croft instead of a second row is an odd one, looks the obvious reserve lock but could it possibly be that SOB covers lock, he is as strong as a horse could be an option?

  2. #152
    Munster Dog of War
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Ireland
    He obviously didn't want to upset Croft and Cuthbert by dropping them straight out of 23 from starting 15. Neither make sense on the bench. Cuthbert out and out wing and Croft a light second row option. Bowe as good a player as he is has done nothing form wise since he came back from injury, I'd say Cuthberts nose is well out of joint.
    Loose head is a real worry. Marcus Horan never went on a Lions tour, it just goes to show that sometimes being a Lion is down to pure luck and scarcity of quality in different generations.

  3. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to tmunster For This Useful Post:


  4. #153
    Munster Praetorian Guard fishooks12's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    I'm not a Leinster fan
    Quote Originally Posted by tmunster View Post
    He obviously didn't want to upset Croft and Cuthbert by dropping them straight out of 23 from starting 15. Neither make sense on the bench. Cuthbert out and out wing and Croft a light second row option. Bowe as good a player as he is has done nothing form wise since he came back from injury, I'd say Cuthberts nose is well out of joint.
    Loose head is a real worry. Marcus Horan never went on a Lions tour, it just goes to show that sometimes being a Lion is down to pure luck and scarcity of quality in different generations.

    Bowe has been in good from since he's come back from Injury. Add even if he hasn't been he's still a much better player than Cuthbert who's glaring defensive weaknesses have been exposed time and again on this tour (Reds game anyone?). That said he can probably feel hard done by considering he took his try well but It's about getting your best team on the field and there is no room for sentiment at this level

  5. #154
    coach Neil Jenkins should be punted, says Jim Tucker

    Jim TuckerThe Courier-MailJune 27, 2013*11:59AM
    How a goalkicking coach is allowed to stand, as a security blanket, a few metres behind star Lions pupil Leigh Halfpenny when he kicks in this Test series against the Wallabies is baffling.He does so under the flimsy title of kicking-tee runner and waterboy. Get Jenkins off the field and standing in the technical zone by the sideline.Tennis mentors in the stands at Wimbledon are castigated for any sign of "coaching" from the bleachers.On the last British and Irish Lions tour in 2001, Phil Larder, the former Britain rugby league international was told to get back in his box for being too overt as a waterboy runner who lingered on the field too long.He was in fact the Lions defensive coach but almost wanted to be a 16th player so chatty and close to the action did he make himself, at times, as he directed players in defence from just behind the line.Jenkins was a marvellous goalkicker in his day to amass a then-world record of 1090 Test points for Wales and the Lions. He is a brilliant kicking coach adding the polish to Halfpenny, who is operating at a superb 27-from-29 success rate on this tour.Jenkins' official Lions title is "assistant coach-goalkicking" so he has no place on the field in a Test match when he can be a comforting presence behind super sniper Halfpenny.Perhaps, the Australian cricket team does need a batting coach standing next to the square leg umpire at Lord's to offer pearls of advice each over in the upcoming Ashes series. Maybe, Jenkins is onto something.The gripe about Jenkins being so overtly present in Halfpenny's kicking routine does not for a moment suggest other teams, including the Wallabies, have not tried to gain little advantages in this area too.When former Wallabies prop Cameron Lillicrap, a qualified physiotherapist, ran water for the Wallabies there was the added bonus of a few on-field words to the front-row because he was also scrum doctor as well.Equally, long-time Wallabies defence coach John Muggleton, part of the 2001 series win over the Lions, ran the water for the Wallabies and clearly added his two-bob's worth on where defensive line corrections could be made.The difference was...they all ran off the field. Jenkins looks as settled in as a Welshman at a bar on St Mary Street in Cardiff who has just ordered his first pint of Brains Bitter.Perhaps, in Australian eyes Jenkins' presence just magnifies the all-bases-covered methods of the Lions.


    We are lucky to have the kickers we have," Jenkins said."It generally is goalkicking that wins or loses Test matches."It's important to stand behind your kicker, watch closely at how he is shaping and how things are going. You saw a kick last Saturday when the tee moved a little and Halfpenny; pushed the ball to the right, but these boys recover quite quickly and move on to the next kick."Jenkins said the Wallabies were letting themselves down by not having a full-time goalkicking coach travelling with the team for this series.South African Braam van Straaten has greatly aided Aussie kickers James O'Connor and co. To be offering feedback by Skype from South Africa while Jenkins is in Halfpenny's back pocket just highlights how the Wallabies have got this one wrong.Former Wallaby Julian Huxley once introduced a goalkicking aid in games at the Queensland Reds where he emptied a trail of sand from a bucket onto the turf to mark his radar for kicks at the goal posts.It just didn't look right and officials barred him from doing it a game or two later. The same goes for Jenkins. It doesn't look right so send him off to the sidelines.
    "Hell, I'm not saying I'm an angel, but when it came to dirty tricks I couldn't hold a candle to the Irish Mafia" Jimmy Hoffa

  6. #155
    Leader of the Red Hordes
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Strange feelings to the selection-

    Happy with the addition of Youngs, Bowe, Lydiate, O'Brien and Murray to their respective positions.
    Concerned about Vunipola and Parling but those are enforced changes and to be fair they probably are the next best candidates. Mystified about Cuthburt and Croft. The idea of putting Croft into the 'row is almost nonsensical, he is many things but a test lock he is not.

    The aussie's also have their own problems especially in the backs where I don't believe either centre can be close to being fit and that O'Connor is not a test level outhalf.

    Big thing this week is accuracy, the Lions should have been out of sight last week but they weren't and it nearly cost them. I would be more optimistic things ought not to be so tight this week.

  7. #156
    Leader of the Red Hordes
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Somewhere you pay for water
    It is a fair point.

  8. #157
    Admiral of the Fleet Evil Omer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by The Outlaw View Post
    I wouldn't see that as a great selection at all to be honest. I'd agree with the Lydiate call in the back-row and Bowe in.

    However I'm not a huge fan of Youngs I think Genia will like to play against him.

    To be honest I wouldn't be a fan of Grant either. Didn't really scrum well on Tuesday and nowhere near as good as Corbisero.

    Parling is enforced. Good honest player but not in the class of POC.

    Think the Aussies will be rubbing their hands on this one.
    sadly have to agree, big test for Youngs is can he avoid a mental breakdown when, not if, the Aussies start to get at him. He won't have the benefit of the solid front 5 of last week to protect him but on the flip side his blindside won't be standing 60m away watching proceedings so he will get a bit of an enforcer getting stuck into them. Equally says it all about Evans and Gray's fall from grace they'd rather play the lightweight option than them. I'm not sure that's as much about still wanting to run around the Aussies, he wouldn't have Lydiate and SOB there if that were the case, as much as those guys have struggled all tour. Having said that having a wing ruck inspector to come on at lock is a massive gamble. Also says it all about Grant that Vunipola is starting. Corbisero played a couple of ho hum performances but they knew he had to start.

    It is a very bold selection (wonder what all this does to Tupuric's relationship with the Wales coaching set up). I know what people are saying about Zebo being unlucky. He is a BOD style of special, has that raging confidence to do things and try things and the physicality and gas to back it up. He is a better all round rugby player than Cuthbert by some distance. BUT if Gatland still wants his tall units out wide style you can see why he's got Cuthbert there. (I've been deliberate on words there because the idea that Zebo isn't a big guy is wrong, Wade is a small winger, Zebo is 6'2 and 15st, he's not small).
    \"A million monkeys with a million crayons would be hard-pressed in a million years to create anything as cretinous as Battlefield Earth.\"

  9. #158
    Admiral of the Fleet Evil Omer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by sewa View Post
    Croft instead of a second row is an odd one, looks the obvious reserve lock but could it possibly be that SOB covers lock, he is as strong as a horse could be an option?
    not sure it works cos SOB is so much shorter, 4-5 inches, that you're going to get a noticeable imbalance on the binds. Could be very odd at 8 because I don't think either AWJ or SOB is a BOD like specimen (with long body and stumpy legs) so you probably would see a difference confronting you. But SOB certainly has the ballast and the oomph, suspect Lydiate does as well and is nearer a body match that works.
    \"A million monkeys with a million crayons would be hard-pressed in a million years to create anything as cretinous as Battlefield Earth.\"

  10. #159
    Admiral of the Fleet Evil Omer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by NotreDameRFC View Post
    coach Neil Jenkins should be punted, says Jim Tucker

    Jim TuckerThe Courier-MailJune 27, 2013*11:59AM
    How a goalkicking coach is allowed to stand, as a security blanket, a few metres behind star Lions pupil Leigh Halfpenny when he kicks in this Test series against the Wallabies is baffling.He does so under the flimsy title of kicking-tee runner and waterboy. Get Jenkins off the field and standing in the technical zone by the sideline.Tennis mentors in the stands at Wimbledon are castigated for any sign of "coaching" from the bleachers.On the last British and Irish Lions tour in 2001, Phil Larder, the former Britain rugby league international was told to get back in his box for being too overt as a waterboy runner who lingered on the field too long.He was in fact the Lions defensive coach but almost wanted to be a 16th player so chatty and close to the action did he make himself, at times, as he directed players in defence from just behind the line.Jenkins was a marvellous goalkicker in his day to amass a then-world record of 1090 Test points for Wales and the Lions. He is a brilliant kicking coach adding the polish to Halfpenny, who is operating at a superb 27-from-29 success rate on this tour.Jenkins' official Lions title is "assistant coach-goalkicking" so he has no place on the field in a Test match when he can be a comforting presence behind super sniper Halfpenny.Perhaps, the Australian cricket team does need a batting coach standing next to the square leg umpire at Lord's to offer pearls of advice each over in the upcoming Ashes series. Maybe, Jenkins is onto something.The gripe about Jenkins being so overtly present in Halfpenny's kicking routine does not for a moment suggest other teams, including the Wallabies, have not tried to gain little advantages in this area too.When former Wallabies prop Cameron Lillicrap, a qualified physiotherapist, ran water for the Wallabies there was the added bonus of a few on-field words to the front-row because he was also scrum doctor as well.Equally, long-time Wallabies defence coach John Muggleton, part of the 2001 series win over the Lions, ran the water for the Wallabies and clearly added his two-bob's worth on where defensive line corrections could be made.The difference was...they all ran off the field. Jenkins looks as settled in as a Welshman at a bar on St Mary Street in Cardiff who has just ordered his first pint of Brains Bitter.Perhaps, in Australian eyes Jenkins' presence just magnifies the all-bases-covered methods of the Lions.


    We are lucky to have the kickers we have," Jenkins said."It generally is goalkicking that wins or loses Test matches."It's important to stand behind your kicker, watch closely at how he is shaping and how things are going. You saw a kick last Saturday when the tee moved a little and Halfpenny; pushed the ball to the right, but these boys recover quite quickly and move on to the next kick."Jenkins said the Wallabies were letting themselves down by not having a full-time goalkicking coach travelling with the team for this series.South African Braam van Straaten has greatly aided Aussie kickers James O'Connor and co. To be offering feedback by Skype from South Africa while Jenkins is in Halfpenny's back pocket just highlights how the Wallabies have got this one wrong.Former Wallaby Julian Huxley once introduced a goalkicking aid in games at the Queensland Reds where he emptied a trail of sand from a bucket onto the turf to mark his radar for kicks at the goal posts.It just didn't look right and officials barred him from doing it a game or two later. The same goes for Jenkins. It doesn't look right so send him off to the sidelines.
    Could we be in the realms of Aussie in whingeing hypocrisy shocker?
    \"A million monkeys with a million crayons would be hard-pressed in a million years to create anything as cretinous as Battlefield Earth.\"

  11. #160
    Quote Originally Posted by Evil Omer View Post
    not sure it works cos SOB is so much shorter, 4-5 inches, that you're going to get a noticeable imbalance on the binds. Could be very odd at 8 because I don't think either AWJ or SOB is a BOD like specimen (with long body and stumpy legs) so you probably would see a difference confronting you. But SOB certainly has the ballast and the oomph, suspect Lydiate does as well and is nearer a body match that works.
    I'm a big fan of Ryan Jones, and make no bones about it. I thought his non-selection was a grievous mistake in a small party. When you have need of a hard-working, grafting, carrying 4/6/8 on the bench of a test side, and are forced to turn to Tom Croft, that mistake is thrown into even sharper relief. It's tailor made for him.

    As it happens, backrow has been a bit of a hames on this. Lots of specialists, but specialists in a different gameplan, only one adaptable player (SOB) in a short, scratch-team, tour. It does look more and more like it would have been wiser to take one or both of Ryan Jones and POM instead of Croft.
    "Let’s do what we’re good at, let’s do what we’re good at... You go after the weakness, you don’t worry what it looks like to anybody else." - Axel.

    "All scrums are sexy." - Nuke.

    "Any day bating Leinster is a good day" - Valencia the Lily-White

  12. #161
    Quote Originally Posted by Evil Omer View Post
    Could we be in the realms of Aussie in whingeing hypocrisy shocker?
    Do we ever get out of them?
    "Let’s do what we’re good at, let’s do what we’re good at... You go after the weakness, you don’t worry what it looks like to anybody else." - Axel.

    "All scrums are sexy." - Nuke.

    "Any day bating Leinster is a good day" - Valencia the Lily-White

  13. #162
    Great Chamberlain of the Red Empire Cowboy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Out riding
    Quote Originally Posted by Thomond78 View Post
    I'm a big fan of Ryan Jones, and make no bones about it. I thought his non-selection was a grievous mistake in a small party. When you have need of a hard-working, grafting, carrying 4/6/8 on the bench of a test side, and are forced to turn to Tom Croft, that mistake is thrown into even sharper relief. It's tailor made for him.

    As it happens, backrow has been a bit of a hames on this. Lots of specialists, but specialists in a different gameplan, only one adaptable player (SOB) in a short, scratch-team, tour. It does look more and more like it would have been wiser to take one or both of Ryan Jones and POM instead of Croft.

    Nathan Hines boss, against his own friends and family. A champion lock and credible blindside who has the link play of an openside. He should have brought him and jettisoned one of Gray or Yanto
    I am the million man.

  14. The Following User Says Thank You to Cowboy For This Useful Post:


  15. #163
    Sin Binned
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Netherlands
    Ryan Jones was a great player, legs are gone though, he'd not last the pace in Oz

  16. #164
    Quote Originally Posted by sewa View Post
    Ryan Jones was a great player, legs are gone though, he'd not last the pace in Oz
    Seemed to do bloody fine this 6N!

    The idea of "hard Australian ground" - it's been raining for most of the bloody games.

    Him or Hines instead of Gray (who is shocking ineffective for a huge lump), and POM for Croft - we'd have been talking. Hey, JO, too late to do anything now.
    "Let’s do what we’re good at, let’s do what we’re good at... You go after the weakness, you don’t worry what it looks like to anybody else." - Axel.

    "All scrums are sexy." - Nuke.

    "Any day bating Leinster is a good day" - Valencia the Lily-White

  17. #165
    Leader of the Red Hordes
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Somewhere you pay for water
    The biggest problem with the back row remains the decision to hand the captaincy to a player who would not in the normal scheme of things be guaranteed his place.

  18. #166
    Leader of the Red Hordes Munsterboy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by Thomond78 View Post
    Seemed to do bloody fine this 6N!

    The idea of "hard Australian ground" - it's been raining for most of the bloody games.

    Him or Hines instead of Gray (who is shocking ineffective for a huge lump), and POM for Croft - we'd have been talking. Hey, JO, too late to do anything now.
    Not at all. Send POC into their room tonight with a bar of soap in a sock and they can be invalided out of the tour in the morning.

  19. #167
    Admiral of the Fleet Evil Omer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Agree about Hines (if another lock) or Jones (if a cover player). Either of them would do the grunt job required. To be honest Hines is unlucky that far less capable players have got more recognition than him. Dare I say it but were he English or Welsh then over the past 5 or so years his praise would have been huge. Especially with Sky Spurts.
    \"A million monkeys with a million crayons would be hard-pressed in a million years to create anything as cretinous as Battlefield Earth.\"

  20. #168
    Admiral of the Fleet Evil Omer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by Munsterboy View Post
    Not at all. Send POC into their room tonight with a bar of soap in a sock and they can be invalided out of the tour in the morning.
    is there anything to be said for doing it anyway?
    \"A million monkeys with a million crayons would be hard-pressed in a million years to create anything as cretinous as Battlefield Earth.\"

  21. #169
    Quote Originally Posted by Munsterboy View Post
    Not at all. Send POC into their room tonight with a bar of soap in a sock and they can be invalided out of the tour in the morning.
    Should have done it Monday. They'll barely get there for kickoff now.

    Quote Originally Posted by Evil Omer View Post
    is there anything to be said for doing it anyway?
    As Ieuan Evans would say: oh, very much so. That, and another mass.
    "Let’s do what we’re good at, let’s do what we’re good at... You go after the weakness, you don’t worry what it looks like to anybody else." - Axel.

    "All scrums are sexy." - Nuke.

    "Any day bating Leinster is a good day" - Valencia the Lily-White

  22. #170
    Leader of the Red Hordes Stanley's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Quote Originally Posted by The Last Stand View Post
    The biggest problem with the back row remains the decision to hand the captaincy to a player who would not in the normal scheme of things be guaranteed his place.

    Biggest problem with the BR is one of them or SH has to nail Beale as he is dropped off by JOC and/or others on an angle at where Sexton was standing before he tracks JOC, Beale comes late against the grain of a drift defence and needs strong decking.

  23. #171
    Great Chamberlain of the Red Empire Cowboy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Out riding
    Quote Originally Posted by Thomond78 View Post
    Gray (who is shocking ineffective for a huge lump)
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Tim-Nice-But-Dim-2.jpg 
Views:	73 
Size:	8.9 KB 
ID:	6938
    I am the million man.

  24. #172
    Admiral of the Fleet Evil Omer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by Thomond78 View Post
    As Ieuan Evans would say: oh, very much so. That, and another mass.
    Got to say had an improved impression of him from the programmes about the 89 tour and a few other things seen. For a "girly back" he's actually a pretty hard lad (2 shoulder dislocation operations by age of 22) and has the right kind of "shoe him" mentality.
    \"A million monkeys with a million crayons would be hard-pressed in a million years to create anything as cretinous as Battlefield Earth.\"

  25. #173
    The IRB have confirmed that they will appeal the James Horwill disciplinary decision following an extensive review of the case.

    With player welfare a key priority for the IRB, they have decided to appeal after Horwill was cleared of stamping on Alun-Wyn Jones in the first Test.

    He is free to play pending the outcome of the appeal.

  26. #174
    My name is Mandy and I live with my mom! i_like_cake's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    By the Bar....
    Thats surprising, but admirable....
    He was as lame as a duck. Not the metaphorical lame duck either, but a real duck that was actually lame. Maybe from stepping on a land mine or something.

  27. #175
    Leader of the Red Hordes Munsterboy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by Thomond78 View Post
    Seemed to do bloody fine this 6N!

    The idea of "hard Australian ground" - it's been raining for most of the bloody games.

    Him or Hines instead of Gray (who is shocking ineffective for a huge lump), and POM for Croft - we'd have been talking. Hey, JO, too late to do anything now.
    If they wanted a quality lock who can play 6, a certain D Ryan would have done the job nicely. Is he injured?

  28. #176
    My name is Mandy and I live with my mom! i_like_cake's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    By the Bar....
    Here´s more info on the IRB and Horwill...
    http://www.irb.com/newsmedia/mediazo...rwill+decision

    so the review will take place after the 2nd test... he´ll probably get a ban for after the 3rd test...

    Continues the citing joke in rugby...
    He was as lame as a duck. Not the metaphorical lame duck either, but a real duck that was actually lame. Maybe from stepping on a land mine or something.

  29. The Following User Says Thank You to i_like_cake For This Useful Post:


  30. #177
    Quote Originally Posted by Balla Boy View Post
    Bowe "covers" fullback in the sense that he can stand there, but he isn't and has never really been a fullback. Can he kick a ball at all?


    It does look stretched, I think. But it's likely to when one of your wingers can only play wing, both your centres can only play centre and you then put the most one dimensional back in the squad on the bench as your cover.

    I think Zebo, Maitland or Hogg would all have offered greater flexibility from the bench.

    Gatland's predilection for 7 foot, 18 stone three quarters doesn't offer great scope to utility backs though.
    Totally Agree. Tuiliagi would have offered more. Literally any other back in the squad would offer more on the bench than Cuthbert, bar Wade.

  31. #178
    Quote Originally Posted by i_like_cake View Post
    Here´s more info on the IRB and Horwill...
    http://www.irb.com/newsmedia/mediazo...rwill+decision

    so the review will take place after the 2nd test... he´ll probably get a ban for after the 3rd test...

    Continues the citing joke in rugby...
    It's quite bizzare insofar as the IRB appointed that guy who presided over the original hearing. Presumably he won't get too many future gigs?

  32. #179
    Quote Originally Posted by Munsterboy View Post
    If they wanted a quality lock who can play 6, a certain D Ryan would have done the job nicely. Is he injured?
    Shoulder's knackered. Flogged himself to death through the 6N for no reward. Gotta have Croftsy...
    "Let’s do what we’re good at, let’s do what we’re good at... You go after the weakness, you don’t worry what it looks like to anybody else." - Axel.

    "All scrums are sexy." - Nuke.

    "Any day bating Leinster is a good day" - Valencia the Lily-White

  33. #180
    Admiral of the Fleet Evil Omer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Quote Originally Posted by i_like_cake View Post
    Here´s more info on the IRB and Horwill...
    http://www.irb.com/newsmedia/mediazo...rwill+decision

    so the review will take place after the 2nd test... he´ll probably get a ban for after the 3rd test...

    Continues the citing joke in rugby...
    the thing is we've seen a string of players in NH get bans for basically being clumsy, where the panel have openly stated that they accept the player did nothing deliberate, was off balance, was pulled off balance etc but they were careless and it impacted the safety of others therefore they got a ban. How the Horwill incident could be viewed any different is nonsensical.
    \"A million monkeys with a million crayons would be hard-pressed in a million years to create anything as cretinous as Battlefield Earth.\"

  34. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Evil Omer For This Useful Post:


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •