I don't think Kilfeacle did anything wrong.
This is my take on it. Kilfeacle won game fair and square. Clanwilliam put in an objection Junior comm threw it out happy that there was nothing in it.
Clanwilliam appealed to Senior Branch and won. Kilfeacle then relegated.
Kilfeacle threatened legal action and Senior comm backed down deciding to leave both Kilfeacle and Clanwilliam in Division 1, as it was obvious Kilfeacle would win in court hands down.
Junior comm have now decided if that if Senior comm decide to leave Kilfeacle back in then Clanwilliam must go down as its messing up their leagues both Division 1 and 2.
If anything its Clanwilliam who are making a mockery of the system.
They are appealing on a technicality or loophole in the law which leaves every result open to question.
Better off taking defeat on the chin, going away and doing the rebuilding they obviously need to do.